Insights

High Court holds that Corporate Veil could be lifted due to Wrongful Trading

Recently in Absa Bank of Uganda Limited and 2 Others v Enjoy Uganda Limited and 2 Others Misc. Appn. 1243 of 2023 the High Court of Uganda held that the corporate veil can be lifted in cases of wrongful trading by a company.

The corporate veil is a legal concept that separates the company from its shareholders and serves to protect the company's shareholders and directors from personal liability for the company's actions.

The Companies Act, Cap. 106, provides the High Court with the power or authority to lift the corporate veil in situations where the company or its directors engage in acts such as tax evasion, fraud, or when the company's membership falls below the statutory minimum.

The recent interpretation of this law extends its application to acts resembling tax evasion or fraud, including making wrongful or fraudulent trading by the directors a ground for lifting the corporate veil. This occurs when such trading results in the deception and defrauding of the company's creditors, constituting a flagrant injustice and improper conduct.

Wrongful or fraudulent trading takes place when a company conducts its business with the intent of purposefully deceiving and defrauding its creditors. This occurs when a company continues to trade as usual, even when its directors are aware (or should have been aware) that the company is insolvent and has no realistic prospect of avoiding formal insolvency.

The key distinction between wrongful and fraudulent trading lies in the intent(or absence of it), with fraudulent trading involving premeditated acts to defraud creditors, while wrongful trading involves trading while knowingly insolvent without proven dishonesty or malicious intent.

The court's ruling establishes that directors can be personally liable for the company's debts if they engage in wrongful trading. Furthermore, directors and shareholders can also be held personally liable for the company's debts and liabilities if they participate in fraudulent transactions. These transactions include:

a) Paying dividends to shareholders when the company is insolvent.
b) Continuing to trade with no intention of repaying company debts.
c) Accepting payments from customers while knowing that goods or services cannot be delivered in return.
d) Attempting to settle debts through fraudulent means.
e) Undervaluing company assets and selling them for less than their market value, either to themselves or third parties.
f) Making preferential payments to certain creditors over others.
g) Engaging in fraudulent trading by providing misleading or inaccurate information on finance applications.
h) Maintaining overdrawn directors' loan accounts.
i) Knowingly permitting the company to act unlawfully, such as breaching employees' contracts, disregarding health and safety or environmental legislation, or misusing sensitive data.

Lifting the corporate veil empowers creditors to hold directors and shareholders personally liable for the company's actions, enabling them to recover debts directly from these individuals.

Conclusion

The court's decision to allow the lifting of the corporate veil in cases of wrongful trading represents a substantial shift in corporate law. It imposes personal liability on directors and shareholders for the company's debts when they engage in wrongful or fraudulent trading. This ruling underscores the importance of transparency and ethical business conduct, as it serves to protect the interests of creditors and promotes fair and responsible corporate practices. Directors and shareholders must exercise prudence and diligence in their roles to avoid personal liability, reinforcing the principle that companies should operate in a manner that ensures their creditors' rights and interests are safeguarded.

DISCLAIMER: This article is for general information only and reflect the position at the date of publication. It does not constitute legal advice. For any further information or advice relating to this article, please contact us.



Discover More News and Insights

Stay informed and deepen your understanding of important legal topics. Explore our extensive library of articles covering various aspects of law, business, finance and more.

Read More Articles